Thermal Gel: Can Its Performance Truly Surpass Thermal Grease?

THERMAL GREASE VETERAN VS. GEL NEWCOMER

Behind the scenes of electronic devices, an invisible battle for heat dissipation rages on, with thermal materials serving as the critical weapons in this war. Thermal grease, the “veteran player” in the heat dissipation field, has a long and distinguished track record. Thermal gel, as a rising star, has also made its mark with unique advantages, showing great potential to overtake its predecessor. Let's take a closer look at these two “players.”

-Thermal Grease: The Veteran of Thermal Management

As a classic thermal interface material, thermal grease—based on organic silicone—has long dominated the electronics thermal management market due to its excellent thermal conductivity, electrical insulation, and ease of application. While its paste-like consistency effectively fills microscopic gaps between components and heat sinks, it suffers from issues like flow resistance, short lifespan (especially prone to drying out in high-temperature environments), and inconsistent performance due to reliance on manual application. These limitations increasingly fail to meet the thermal demands of modern electronics, which prioritize thinness and high performance.

In computer CPU cooling, thermal grease acts as a bridge connecting the heat source (CPU) to the heat dissipation “fortress” (heatsink). Yet this ‘bridge’ harbors a hidden risk: prolonged exposure to high temperatures causes it to “crack and dry out,” obstructing heat transfer. As CPU temperatures soar, computers begin to crash frequently and experience lag.

-Thermal Gel: The Emerging “Cooling Star”

Thermal gel is a gel-like thermal interface material that has gained prominence in recent years. It is manufactured using vacuum processes, featuring a polymer matrix blended with conductive components like metal powders and oxide fillers. It inherits silicone's advantages of weather resistance, high/low temperature tolerance (-40°C to 200°C long-term operation), and excellent insulation. Simultaneously, it possesses unique high viscosity and low hardness properties, functioning like a “liquid thermal pad” to provide superior solutions for complex cooling scenarios.

It functions like soft modeling clay filled between a heat-generating chip and a heat sink, perfectly conforming to uneven surfaces without deformation or displacement.

WHY IS THERMAL GEL CHALLENGING THERMAL GREASE?

In the competitive arena of thermal management materials, thermal gel stands out among numerous rivals to challenge thermal grease's dominant position—and it must have exceptional qualities to do so. Below, we delve into the five core advantages of thermal gel.

- Application Process Traditional thermal grease application relies heavily on manual spreading or screen printing—inefficient methods prone to environmental contamination. Thickness depends entirely on the applicator's experience, making it difficult to ensure even coverage in gaps exceeding 0.2mm, which significantly compromises cooling performance. Imagine a large-scale electronics manufacturing plant where workers meticulously apply thermal grease to each component with small brushes. This method is not only slow but also produces inconsistent quality, making it incapable of meeting the rapid demands of modern electronics production. Thermal gel has revolutionized this process. Packaged in syringes and applied via fully automated dispensing machines, it enables precise, metered application and seamless automation. This leap is akin to transitioning from a small, manual workshop to a modern smart factory, significantly boosting production efficiency. On the assembly lines of major smartphone manufacturers, dispensing machines methodically apply thermal gel evenly between chips and heat sinks. Each application is precise in both quantity and placement, not only enhancing production speed but also ensuring consistent product quality.

-Interface Adaptation The contact surfaces between electronic components and heat sinks appear smooth but harbor numerous microscopic irregularities at the micrometer scale. While thermal grease possesses some fluidity, its excessive thinness causes it to behave like water poured onto uneven ground when filling these complex interfaces. This often results in air bubbles or uneven distribution. These bubbles and irregularities act like hidden “roadblocks” within the heat transfer pathways, obstructing efficient thermal conduction. Thermal gel, however, acts like a magical “plasticine.” Its high elasticity and low modulus enable it to adaptively conform to any irregular surface when applied between electronic components and heat sinks. No matter how minute or intricate the gaps, it fills them tightly, eliminating air pockets and significantly reducing contact thermal resistance. Even at thicknesses of just a few hundred micrometers, it performs flawlessly, enabling smoother heat transfer. In high-end server cooling systems, thermal gel effortlessly fills microscopic grooves on chip surfaces, achieving efficient heat transfer and ensuring stable operating temperatures during prolonged, high-load server operation.

-Lifespan and Stability Thermal grease's lifespan has long been its weak point. Over time, especially in high-temperature environments, it tends to degrade through oil separation, drying out, and hardening. Much like cooking oil that spoils when left unused, these changes cause its thermal performance to gradually decline until it ultimately fails. Statistics show that conventional thermal grease experiences significant performance degradation after 2-3 years in high-temperature environments, necessitating frequent replacement. This not only increases maintenance costs but also disrupts normal equipment operation. Thermal gel, however, boasts exceptional longevity and stability through its unique formulation. It remains permanently pliable and infinitely compressible—like a sponge that never loses its elasticity—consistently maintaining superior thermal conductivity. Even under harsh thermal cycling conditions—from scorching summers to freezing winters—it maintains stable physical properties with a service life exceeding 10 years. In automotive electronics, whether deployed in scorching desert regions or frigid polar environments, thermal gel delivers enduring, reliable thermal management, ensuring stable operation of vehicle electronic systems.

-Advanced Functionality Thermal gel isn't just about heat transfer—it possesses multiple “hidden capabilities.” Beyond its outstanding thermal conductivity (up to 3–10 W/m·K or higher), enabling rapid heat dissipation, it also offers electrical insulation and shock/vibration absorption. In high-voltage electronic environments, it acts as a robust insulating armor. Its high resistivity effectively prevents leakage risks, safeguarding both equipment and personnel. In vibration-prone scenarios like automotive electronics, it functions as a cushioning pad, absorbing and buffering stresses on components. This reduces contact failures caused by mechanical vibrations, delivering dual benefits of “thermal management + protection.” Within the battery management systems of new energy vehicles, thermal gel not only aids battery heat dissipation but also prevents short circuits. Simultaneously, it cushions vibrations during vehicle operation, providing comprehensive protection for the safe and stable functioning of the battery.

www.zesongmaterial.com
Zesong